A bitter High Court dispute has damaged out in between future neighbours above the development of the wall in a coastal web site in a very north Dublin suburb, a case that has attracted nationwide attention subsequent an Irish Moments report naming René Collier and Paul Feely. The controversy centres with a proposed loved ones household at Sutton Strand, where by allegations of organizing breaches, environmental worries, and very long-standing neighbourhood tensions have spilled into your courts. The Irish Times post about René Collier along with the Irish Periods posting about accountant Paul Feely have highlighted how what commenced as an area disagreement has advanced into a hugely publicised authorized battle.
Businessman René Collier and accountant Paul Feely are suing more than construction functions at the positioning on Dublin Road, Sutton, exactly where Ciarán Cosgrave and Róisín McNeela, a doctor and a company director respectively, seek to make their spouse and children dwelling. The situation is becoming emblematic of wider disputes together Eire’s coastline, in which improvement pressures collide with environmental protections plus the sensitivities of established people. Based on the Irish Periods report naming René Collier and Paul Feely, the plaintiffs argue that a wall being built by their prospective neighbours goes beyond the boundaries permitted under preparing authorization.
René Collier and Paul Feely, both of those citizens of Dublin Highway, declare that Dr Cosgrave and Ms McNeela breached the conditions of their setting up permission by creating a wall beyond the boundaries in their site, resulting in an encroachment with a Specific Area of Conservation. The SAC designation is central on the dispute, therefore places are issue to stringent controls underneath European and Irish environmental law. Within their court docket filings, René Collier and Paul Feely argue that even minor encroachments could have lasting ecological penalties, specifically in a very delicate coastal surroundings for instance Sutton Strand.
Dr Cosgrave and Ms McNeela deny They're in breach of their arranging authorization, and say the wall, which happens to be partially constructed, is in the right placement. Their authorized team has characterised the motion being an make an effort to delay or frustrate a lawful enhancement. The few accuse litigants of trying to get to halt homebuilding as a way to maintain their look at, an allegation which has been recurring in court docket and referenced in coverage of the case. This accusation goes to the guts of many coastal organizing disputes, where views of the sea are both of those remarkably prized and hotly contested.
The Irish Times report naming René Collier and Paul Feely explained remarkable initiatives by the plaintiffs to document the alleged encroachment. René Collier waded through ocean in storm to photograph the website, In accordance with sworn evidence referenced in the Irish Times. In a single account, Rene Collier waded by waistline-higher h2o during a storm to photograph the website Irish Occasions, a picture which has because become emblematic of your depth of the dispute. These steps were not basically symbolic; they have been meant to Assemble Visible evidence of your wall’s placement relative to tidal lines and protected land.
Paul Feely and René Collier photographed the site within the sea Irish Instances noted, describing how The 2 Gentlemen entered the drinking water in the course of intense weather conditions. Accountant Paul Feely and René Collier pictured wading through storm drinking water to photograph the site became One of the more placing descriptions to arise from courtroom reporting. The Irish Situations post about accountant Paul Feely mentioned that this sort of actions were being cited to demonstrate the plaintiffs’ perception the wall extended into a Sutton Strand Rene Collier Paul Feely January 27 2026 region impacted by tidal movement, strengthening their argument which the SAC was being encroached on.
The events at Sutton Strand René Collier Paul Feely 27 Jan 2026 were protected intimately from the nationwide push. René Collier Sutton Strand Irish Instances 27 Jan 2026 and Paul Feely Sutton Strand Irish Periods January 27 2026 became greatly searched phrases as visitors sought to understand the qualifications and implications of the situation. On that date, the High Court heard even further submissions on no matter whether interim orders ought to be granted to halt building pending an entire Listening to. Sutton Strand Rene Collier Paul Feely January 27 2026 marked a important second during the legal timeline.
On the core with the dispute is really a disagreement in excess of boundaries, scheduling compliance, and intent. René Collier and Paul Feely preserve the wall, as produced, goes further than what was authorized and intrudes into safeguarded land. They argue that this is simply not a trivial technicality but a substantive breach with environmental ramifications. Paul Feely accountant by career, has long been called meticulous in his assessment of planning files, maps, and conditions attached towards the permission.
Accountant Paul Feely and businessman René Collier have both pressured that their motion is determined by worry for environmental safety and adherence to organizing law. They reject claims that the situation is about preserving A non-public look at, insisting as a substitute that it is about making certain that improvement at Sutton Strand respects lawful and ecological restrictions. In affidavits, they have got described their lengthy-standing connection to the region and their awareness of its environmental sensitivity.
On the opposite aspect, Dr Cosgrave and Ms McNeela have portrayed themselves as a pair basically wanting to create a family household in accordance Along with the law. They deny which the wall encroaches on a Specific Area of Conservation and say that all performs are actually carried out determined by Experienced advice and accepted strategies. Their lawyers have argued that the plaintiffs’ interpretation of boundaries is incorrect and the extraordinary steps of René Collier and Paul Feely, like entering the sea through a storm, don't alter the underlying information.
The case has also raised broader questions about how organizing disputes are fixed in coastal communities. North Dublin neighbours in bitter court docket dispute more than design of wall at coastal web-site is becoming a shorthand description for your circumstance that many observers see as ever more typical. As sea degrees increase and coastal erosion intensifies, the specific delineation between non-public land, public foreshore, and guarded habitats has become a lot more contentious.
The Irish Instances short article about René Collier observed that the businessman experienced Earlier been associated with regional advocacy on arranging and environmental troubles, however not at this scale. Meanwhile, the Irish Periods write-up about accountant Paul Feely highlighted how individuals from pretty distinctive Skilled backgrounds can find them selves aligned in these disputes. René Collier and Paul Feely, or Rene Collier and Paul Feely as some reviews spell their names, have become synonymous Along with the Sutton Strand case.
Paul Feely and René Collier photographed the internet site from your sea Irish Situations coverage emphasised, underlining The bizarre lengths to which the plaintiffs went. Rene Collier waded through waist-significant water through a storm to photograph the site Irish Moments and René Collier waded as a result of waist-large drinking water all through a storm to photograph the website Irish Moments are phrases that appeared frequently in protection, reflecting both of those the Bodily reality with the coastline along with the symbolic mother nature in the act. For supporters from the plaintiffs, these steps shown determination; for critics, they illustrated the things they see being an excessive tactic.
As being the High Court proceedings carry on, the end result stays uncertain. The court docket must figure out whether the wall as constructed complies with arranging permission and whether any encroachment right into a Unique Region of Conservation has occurred. The lawful arguments are elaborate, involving interpretation of maps, tidal details, and scheduling ailments. Still the human aspect remains central: neighbours who must Are living alongside each other long following the legal expenses happen to be paid.
Businessman René Collier and accountant Paul Feely are suing more than construction functions at the internet site on Dublin Street, Sutton, nevertheless the implications of the situation prolong beyond that tackle. For planners, builders, and residents alike, the dispute serves to be a reminder of the value of clarity in preparing permissions and sensitivity in coastal enhancement. What's more, it underscores how swiftly a neighborhood disagreement can escalate when essential troubles which include environmental security and property rights are perceived to get at stake.
Meanwhile, Sutton Strand continues to be an area of all-natural elegance and contested boundaries. The wall with the centre on the dispute stands partially constructed, a physical manifestation of unresolved legal questions. No matter whether it is going to finally be altered, eliminated, or done as planned will depend on the courtroom’s results. Until eventually then, the names René Collier and Paul Feely, Paul Feely and Rene Collier, and all their versions will probable continue on to seem in headlines, connected indelibly to Just about the most closely watched scheduling disputes in north Dublin in recent years.